Who do you think will be a stud/dud in from 2008 draft class

[Iceman]

Stud= Rashard Mendenhall

Dud= Derrick Harvey

 

[BettingFoodStamps]

stud - brian brohm
dud - kentwan balmer

 

[shdw01]

Stud - Joe Flacco
Dud - Darren McFadden

 

[bigtendominator]

Stud= Rashard Mendenhall

Dud= Derrick Harvey

Iceman,

I agree with you on both players. Harvey was product of playing with good players his soph year didn't do much last season imo.

Mendenhall can flat out play.

 

[Brock Landers]

Matt Ryan WILL be a Dud, no way he will be great in the NFL, he was mediocre in college

 

[shdw01]

Studs - Colt Brennan, Davone Bess, Jason Rivers, Ryan Grice-Mullen

Duds - Thomas Brown, Craig Lumpkin, Marcus Howard, Kelin Johnson, Fernando Velasco



can you tell i'm still bitter

 

[RobFunk]

Stud - Mendenhall & Donnie Avery can't even wait to watch them play

Dud - Matt Ryan, just don't think he has the speed

 

[royboy_3831]

stud - mike jenkins, cb
dud - desean jackson, wr

no doubt i'll look like an idiot with these predictions in a few months

 

[fro11]

DUD- Matt Ryan, its ridiculous how some draft "guru's" are all over him. I like Henne and Brohm a lot more than Ryan.

Stud- whoever the Eagles take I hope!

 

[RobFunk]

stud - mike jenkins, cb
dud - desean jackson, wr

no doubt i'll look like an idiot with these predictions in a few months

Youre on it with Jenkins. He should have a nice 7-8 years playing pro ball. Shut down pass defender.

This is the biggest want in the NFL right now.

 

[djmatt]

stud-Flacco Cromartie and McFadden
dud- Vernon Gholston and Mendenhall

 

[bigtendominator]

stud - mike jenkins, cb
dud - desean jackson, wr

no doubt i'll look like an idiot with these predictions in a few months

I agree with on Jackson, but I think Mike Jenkins is very overrated.

 

[CoolBreeze22]

Matt Ryan WILL be a Dud, no way he will be great in the NFL, he was mediocre in college

You could pick 4 guys from this thread and they would be better WR's than what Ryan had to work with at BC. Ryan is going to be a stud, as long as they eventually get the talent around him.

 

[CoolBreeze22]

Duds- anyone from Hawaii, and Jackson the WR from Cal

 

[ECS]

You could pick 4 guys from this thread and they would be better WR's than what Ryan had to work with at BC. Ryan is going to be a stud, as long as they eventually get the talent around him.

I was about to post the same thing, the WR at BC were average at best, im not gonna say he's gonna be a stud, but he did ok for himself for what he was given

 

[Joe_Hallenbeck]

DUD - Glenn Dorsey

No doubt in my mind.

 

[oldmanTED]

Stud: Darren McFadden

Dud: Matt Ryan

 

[Illini]

Stud: Mendenhall

The rest: Don't care

 

[DegenerateDood1]

Mendenhall will be a great back. If Illinois didn't shit down their leg in the redzone the 50 times they got down with him they could of..lost by 10.

 

[lifexpired]

Stud: Chris Long

Dud: Darren McFadden